The fall season on Anna Maria Island feels like a well-kept secret. The summer crowds have thinned out and the weather is warm without being stifling. Sunsets arrive with a golden softness that lingers longer over the Gulf. This quieter season is the perfect time to savor the island’s food scene that ranges from sandy-toed seafood shacks to white-tablecloth fine dining. Here’s our guide to the must-try fall spots for
dining on Anna Maria Island and what makes each of them special:
Browse Our Fall Anna Maria Island Rentals Here!
Beachfront & Scenic Seafood Spots
The Waterfront Restaurant
Many of our vacation rentals are just steps from the historic Anna Maria City Pier. You can find The Waterfront Restaurant here that blends laid-back island charm with sophisticated flavors. Their menu highlights fresh, locally caught seafood prepared with an elegant twist. Popular menu items include the grouper topped with citrus beurre blanc or creamy shrimp and grits with a Southern accent. The restaurant’s wraparound porch is the prime spot for a fall evening where you can feel the cooler breezes roll in off the bay and see occasional dolphin appearances out in the distance.
The Sandbar Restaurant
Vacation means slipping your toes in the sand as you sip a cocktail. The Sandbar is famous for its beachside tables that give guests an unobstructed view of the sunset, one of the most memorable fall rituals on the island. Their menu leans heavily on Gulf staples like stone crab claws, oysters, and blackened fish tacos. You can also find elevated classics with fresh herbs and produce from local farms.
Beach House Waterfront Restaurant
The Beach House Waterfront Restaurant is the sister property of The Sandbar and is all about sustainability and style. The sprawling deck provides a panoramic Gulf view, while the menu offers dishes like seared scallops with truffle risotto and line-caught grouper prepared with seasonal accompaniments. This is an excellent choice for a romantic dinner or a celebratory meal during your stay as it features a more upscale appearance than The Sandbar too.
Casual & Local Eateries
The Porch Restaurant
Find a relaxed meal in a charming coastal cottage when you dine at The Porch. This restaurant mixes casual
dining on Anna Maria Island with unexpectedly refined flavors. Their menu ranges from fresh salads to hearty sandwiches, with seasonal sides like roasted Brussels sprouts or butternut squash that are perfect for fall. The setting feels cozy and inviting making it an ideal spot for a leisurely lunch or relaxed family dinner.
Wicked Cantina
Bold Tex-Mex flavors meet island breezes when you dine at Wicked Cantina. The vibe is playful with brightly colored décor and a lively outdoor patio. Tacos filled with mahi or brisket pair perfectly with one of their house margaritas and their queso is a local favorite. Grab a seat outside during the fall where you can people-watch and soak in the warm but comfortable weather.
The Ugly Grouper
Whether you like it fried, grilled, blackened, or tucked into tacos you will find that The Ugly Grouper serves up the best grouper entrees around. What makes this fun named restaurant especially memorable is its atmosphere. The open-air seating under a huge tiki-style canopy, live music most evenings, and a playful, family-friendly vibe bring it all together. The giant grouper statue out front makes for a fun photo op too!
Upscale and Fine Dining on Anna Maria Island
Old Bay Steamer
Old Bay Steamer has been considered one of Florida’s best fine-dining destinations. It is known for its impeccable service and Gulf-view tables along with indulgent of seafood and of course oysters. A reservation in advance is typically needed for this sought after restaurant.
Breakfast & Sweet Spots
The Coffee Shack
This coffee shop is a favorite of travelers and locals alike. Grab a quick bite from their selection of breakfast sandwiches and pastries while you sip on your morning espresso or latte of choice. But it’s the owners and workers who are the biggest draw. They’ll make your day with friendly service.
Ginny’s and Jane E’s Café and Gift Shop
Ginny’s and Jane E’s is part café, part bakery, and part local market with lively colors inside. Their giant cinnamon rolls are legendary and their Cuban breakfast sandwich is a hearty way to fuel up for a day at the beach.
North Shore Café
North Shore Café is perfect for a serene start to your morning on the northern side of Anna Maria Island. They serve high-quality coffee, smoothie bowls, and fresh pastries on a shady patio with water views, perfect for the fall weather.
The Donut Experiment
Fun and interactive, this shop lets you customize your own donuts with glazes, toppings, and drizzles. It’s a hit with kids, but just as delightful for adults craving a playful sugar fix.
Browse Our Anna Maria Island Condos Here!
Your Time on Anna Maria Island
Anna Maria Island in the fall is a blend of quiet charm and culinary adventure. Each of these wonderful restaurants can lead you on a culinary journey like no other. Reserve one of our rentals today and start planning ahead to dine your way across Anna Maria Island!Anna Maria Island is a hidden gem tucked along the stunning coastline of Florida's Gulf of Mexico. With its
pristine beaches, turquoise waters, and laid-back charm, this island paradise offers a tranquil escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. Whether you're a nature enthusiast, a sun seeker, or a food lover, Anna Maria Island has something for everyone. To the gastronomes, here's a culinary journey, exploring the best
dining on Anna Maria Island. Get ready to excite your taste buds with a delectable array of flavors and discover the culinary delights that await you on this enchanting island.
Browse Our Full Selection of Rentals Here!
Prepare Your Palate for a Culinary Excursion
As you stroll along the charming streets of Anna Maria Island, your senses will be enticed by the inviting aromas wafting from the local eateries. One must-visit spot is the lively Poppo's Taqueria, where you can savor the authentic flavors of Mexican street food. From their hand-pressed tortillas to their flavorful fillings, every bite at Poppo's is a fiesta for your taste buds.
Craving some coastal cuisine? Look no further than The Waterfront Restaurant, a beloved establishment that embodies the island's laid-back vibe. With stunning views of the bay and a menu showcasing the freshest catch of the day, this waterfront gem offers a true taste of Anna Maria Island. Whether you opt for their succulent grilled fish or their signature seafood pasta, you won't be disappointed.
For those seeking a taste of Italy, Vinny's Italian Kitchen is a hidden gem that should not be missed. This family-owned restaurant captures the essence of traditional Italian cooking, serving up classic dishes with a modern twist. From their homemade pasta to their wood-fired pizzas, each bite is a celebration of flavors that will transport you to the heart of Italy.
If you're in the mood for a casual yet unforgettable dining experience, The Ugly Grouper is the place to be. Known for its vibrant atmosphere and mouthwatering burgers, this local hotspot is a favorite among both tourists and locals. Whether you choose their signature Grouper Reuben or their loaded nachos, you'll leave with a satisfied appetite and a smile on your face.
Craving a refreshing treat? Swing by Two Scoops Ice Cream, a charming ice cream parlor that serves up handcrafted frozen delights. With a wide array of flavors ranging from classic vanilla to exotic creations, Two Scoops is a haven for ice cream enthusiasts. You can treat yourself to a scoop (or two!) of their creamy creations and indulge in the sweetness of Anna Maria Island.
As the sun sets over the Gulf of Mexico, make your way to the Sandbar Seafood & Spirits for a memorable dining experience by the beach. This iconic eatery offers a unique blend of coastal cuisine, breathtaking views, and a touch of romance. With your toes in the sand and the sound of waves in the background, enjoy their delectable seafood dishes while relishing the island's natural beauty.
Whether you're a foodie or simply someone who appreciates a good meal, Anna Maria Island has an abundance of culinary delights to offer. From fresh seafood to international flavors, the island's restaurants cater to a wide range of tastes and preferences. So, take a break from your beach activities, venture into the local eateries, and embark on a gastronomic journey that will leave you craving for more. Anna Maria Island is not just a vacation destination; it's a culinary paradise waiting to be explored.
Enjoy Comfort in a Coastal Paradise
When it comes to finding the perfect vacation rental, our properties on Anna Maria Island offer unparalleled experiences. Our vacation rentals feature designs that provide you with the ultimate comfort and convenience. Get ready to immerse yourself in the island life with our spacious and tastefully decorated accommodations. From cozy beach cottages to
luxurious waterfront villas, we have a wide range of options to suit every traveler's needs.
Get ready to enjoy the serenity of your own private oasis, complete with modern amenities that will make you feel right at home. Imagine waking up to the soothing sound of waves, sipping your morning coffee on a private balcony overlooking the azure waters, or unwinding in a private pool surrounded by lush tropical gardens.
Our vacation rentals are also thoughtfully equipped with everything you need for a memorable stay. Guests can experience the convenience of fully equipped kitchens, allowing them to prepare delicious meals with ease. You can also stay connected with complimentary high-speed internet access and indulge in your favorite entertainment with flat-screen TVs and premium cable channels.
The proximity to the beach is another highlight of our vacation rentals. With many properties just steps away from the powdery sand and crystal-clear waters, you can spend your days basking in the sun, swimming, or engaging in thrilling water sports.
Book Your Stay in One of Our Remarkable Rentals
Anna Maria Island boasts a vibrant local culture, offering an array of dining, shopping, and entertainment options. Get ready to explore charming boutiques, dine at waterfront restaurants, or attend cultural events and festivals that showcase the island's unique charm. So why wait? You can contact us to book your dream vacation rental on Anna Maria Island today and embark on an unforgettable coastal getaway.
We Offer Rentals With Private Pools!Stretching white sand beaches, an expanse of turquoise-blue water, and tropical vibes along the Gulf of Mexico—it's a typical summer vacation to Anna Maria Island, where you can indulge in the best of the beach life and escape the summer heat, whether it’s by taking a dip in the ocean or sipping on a Mai Tai poolside. Beyond all the outdoor activities you can get up to, you’ll find that it’s a great season for outdoor dining, feasting on freshly caught seafood, and admiring waterfront views. If you’re interested in some of the best outdoor dining spots, we have a selection of recommendations for a variety of cuisine and tastes! Check out our list of best summer outdoor dining on Anna Maria Island below!
Check Out Local Restaurants
Rod and Reel Pier
Located at the north end of the island facing out toward Tampa Bay, this casual two-story joint is situated at the end of a pier, offering beautiful views of the striking Gulf water and sailboats drifting around the bay. Wake up early to grab breakfast and a Bloody Mary on their patio or dine out for a romantic evening and enjoy dishes like Coconut Almond Mahi to the sound of the waves splashing against the pier. They offer a daily selection of fresh fish, as well as steak and chicken dishes!
You can find Rod and Reel Pier at 875 N Shore Dr, Anna Maria, FL 34216, or give them a call at 941-778-1885!
The Sandbar
This restaurant can be found right on the gorgeous beach, with a large outdoor patio that also offers tables right in the sand! With generously sized umbrellas, it’s a great spot to kick back and enjoy some fresh oysters on the half shell with your choice of an afternoon cocktail. Vegetarians and even vegans will rejoice, as this spot has options for plant-based diners as well, such as their Vegan Burger. You’ll also find an assortment of delicious dishes like Chicken and Waffles and Fish Tacos. With gluten-free options, there’s something for everyone on this menu!
You can find The Sandbar at 100 Spring Ave, Anna Maria, FL 34216, or give them a call at 941-778-0444!
Island Ocean Star
If you’re a fan of sushi, you’ll love this Japanese spot, which has a great location mid-island, right on the marina overlooking Bimini Bay. Their large building offers a spacious upper deck, where you can relax in the breeze and check out the names of the boats docked in the harbor. Offering an assortment of nigiri, sashimi, and signature rolls, they have an extensive sushi menu, but also offer a selection of gyoza, yakisoba noodle entrees, tempura entrees, teriyaki, and katsu.
You can find Island Ocean Star at 902 S Bay Blvd, Anna Maria, FL 34216, or call them at 941-251-6940!
Anna Maria Island Beach Café
If you’re looking for a more casual spot on the beach, where you can dig your toes into the sand and order an ice-cold beverage, a few appetizers, and chat for a few hours, look no further than Anna Maria Island Beach Café! This adorable café also has tables in the sand, with shading umbrellas perfect for the summertime. Offering a lively assortment of colorful cocktails and even a robust morning breakfast menu, you can find a variety of American-fusion eats, such as sandwiches, salads, burgers, and tacos. Whether you’re hanging out with friends or bringing the whole family, this café is a great spot right on the shore!
You can find Anna Maria Island Beach Café at 4000 Gulf Dr, Holmes Beach, FL 34217, or give them a call at 941-778-0784!
Reserve Your Summer Getaway with SeaBreeze Vacation Today!
If you’ve been thinking about booking your summer getaway to AMI, there’s never been a better time than now! We’re pleased to offer a variety of
Anna Maria Island vacation homes for rent, from locations right on the shore to homes with stunning backyard pools and jacuzzies. If you’d like to learn more about reserving one of
our vacation homes for your summer vacation, give our friendly team a call today—we're waiting to hear from you! Make sure to check out our
boat deck rentals too!
Contact Us Today!
